Lacking Only The Ale
by: David White
Should Auld Acquaintance Be Forgot contains historically accurate performances by harpsichordist Kenneth Cooper and a crackerjack ensemble of some rather well-known, well-worn old tunes.
There is "Yanky Doodle," which, according to Kenneth Cooper's fascinating liner notes, first appeared as an instrumental reel in a collection of music printed in Glasgow in the late 1700s. It predates even that; having been used (but not composed) by James Aird in his opera The Disappointment, but publishers found it difficult to print a tune known for its "off-color texts." One of the oldest tunes on this recording is "Three Blinde Mice." Cooper claims there are double entendres to be found here, but I don't get 'em; it's still cute, though.
"Jingle Bells" is pretty much what we're used to, but harmony students take note: there's a surprise chord change at "Jingle all the way." "Vaterland, in deinen Gauen" is the Christmas carol "Hark! the Herald-angels sing" in its original setting (in German, of course) by its composer, Felix Mendelssohn. Of interest here is the restoration of the middle section. (There was one missing? Yes.) The original was the second movement of a tribute to printer/inventor Johann Gutenberg, Fest-Gesang fur Mannerchor (Festival song for men's chorus). Gutenberg was praised not only for his German nationality, but for "the enlightenment in reading and learning that resulted from the invention of printing."
Another recognizable Yuletide tune is "Adestes Fideles" or "O Come, All Ye Faithful," but don't get smug too soon. The original was in triple meter and utilized some surprising syncopations; it's quite lively and enjoyable. "Tempus adest floridum" ("Now Is the Time for Flowering") is, of course, "Good King Wenceslas" and dates back to the 1582 Piae Cantiones Ecclesiasticae collection, while the Welsh love song "Nos Galan" is none other than "Deck the Halls."
"To Anachreon in Heaven" was written for the Anacreontic society to honor the Greek poet, a specialist in wine, women, and poetry, as its "patron." Cooper assigns various roles (Narrator, Anacreon, etc.) to the members of his ensemble for maximum fun; you'll get a kick out of it.
Other works on the recording are Benjamin Carr's "Federal Overture" (which includes such gems as "Yankee Doodle," "La Marseillaise," and "O Dear, What Can the Matter Be"), "God Save our Lord the King" (now sung with "Queen" by the English and as "My Country 'Tis of Thee" by us folk), and "To Celia," whose words we know as "Drink to Me Only with Thine Eyes." The tune to this last one is very different from what we're used to; Cooper suggests William Boyce or Thomas Arne as possible composers of this mid-18th century version. The more familiar tune was written 20 years later by that famous composer Anonymous.
James Hook's "Christmas Box" of the late 1790s contains settings of nursery rhymes; it makes you realize that they were probably sung in the first place. "Auld lang syne" is a fitting end to the recording; I, for one, wished for more, and felt a type of nostalgia (for past lives?) that "Auld lang syne" captured quite well.
Mr. Cooper is to be commended for everything about this recording; his own harpsichord and piano playing is simply exquisite, and his vocal ensemble, soprano Josephine Mongiardo, mezzo-soprano Constance Beavon, tenors Jon Garrison and Daniel Pincus, bass-baritone Michael Riley, and bass Craig Timberlake, are right on in pitch and emotional temperament. Judith Mendenhall's flute and Betsy Blachly's bells also add instrumental color on occasion to good effect.
In his notes, Cooper tells us that it would have been "unauthentic, not to say unsporting" to have eschewed the sheer entertainment value of this music for the strictly historical approach. As a result, he says, the recording sessions "were lacking only the ale." You can tell this is true: I strongly suggest you purchase this recording and play it while hoisting a "tall frosty one" to Anacreon and to Kenneth Cooper and his merry band.
REDISCOVER THE JOY OF LISTENING
Get discounts on almost every purchase - and see about benefits from our partner store, ClassicSelect World.