Listen to This Story:

Est. Reading Time: 5 min

Chips From Beethoven's Workbench

Chips from Beethoven's workbench: this record reminded me--as so many things do these days--of time's swift and inexorable passage. To put it another way, it, to all intents and purposes, signalizes the end of a cycle. You will note that, like most recor­dings now produced by MHS, it is available in three formats: LP, cassette, and CD. I have no doubt that there are folks out there who deplore the fact that it is not offered in 78-rpm shellacs. There may even still be those who would prefer to have it single­-sided horn-recorded, with grit in the grooves to keep the "needle" sharp. Be that as it may, I am seeing the end of another cycle. The LP revolution, which has lasted exactly 40 years, is as surely on its way out as were 78s in 1948. 


Back then (God, it's wonderful to be old enough to have a historical perspective!) it was more than a matter of a more con­venient way of hearing music. Instead of having to leap up every four minutes to change the record (or wait for the wheeze­-and-crash of the changer) one could listen uninterrupted for at least a third of an hour. (As with early CDs, the manufac­turers were not very generous with time.) But prior to that day, we were largely dependent for our recorded fare on the RCA and Columbia catalogs. These were limited to the works whose sales were pret­ty well guaranteed and the artists the two corporations had nominated for lasting fame; what was available changed only minimally over the years.


When Columbia introduced the LP (which RCA scorned until it looked too sil­ly to keep it up), the list consisted mostly of reprocessed catalog offerings. But by 1950 little new companies began to pop up all over the place, producing often unheard-of repertoire played by equally unheard-of artists. The weekly visit to the local record shop became a voyage of discovery. (Yes, Virginia, there were local record stores, staffed by knowledgeable people, of whom I was one on occasion.) One such company was Westminster, the brainchild of Michael Naida, who later fathered MHS.


In its first release was WL5003, contain­ing Beethoven's wind sextet and octet played by the Vienna Philharmonic Wind Group. I had never heard of the works. The VPWG did not have the Red Seal stamp of Approval, and I was convinced that the Vienna orchestra could not hold a rushlight to those of Philadelphia and New York, but I bought the record anyway--and played it to death. (Actually I still have the thing in its plain maroon sleeve, and, considering age and hard usage, it still sounds pretty good!)


These are, mind you, not masterpieces. (I discover that I swiped the "chips" image from Harold Schonberg's chamber music volume in the Knopf Guide to Long-Playing Records [1955], which I hadn't consulted in years!) They are apprentice works and intended as Gebrauchsmusik-- a background to party chatter. 


Listen to the first movement "Adagio - Allegro con brio" from Beethoven's Septet in E-Flat Major, Op. 20

Indeed, during Beethoven's lifetime, the Septet (Op.20), composed about 1799-1800, was probably his best known work and arrangements proliferated (a keyboard version of the Tempo di Minuetto" is still a staple in many collections of piano music). The conductor Arturo Toscanini was particularly fond of the Septet, and performed and recorded his own orchestral version. According to Toscanini scholar Mortimer H. Frank, the Maestro felt he couldn't attain the right balance with just violin, viola, cello, double bass, clarinet, horn and   bassoon   and   so   augmented   it   to contain 12 violins, 10 violas, eight cellos and five double basses. (And they said Stokowski took liberties!) Toscanini has left us a charming, invigorating performance of "his" Septet, but most listeners will be quite content with Beethoven's original: if it is not the composer at his most profound, it surely represents him at his most purely "likeable."

 

Listen to the Rondo from Beethoven's Sextet in E-Flat Major, Op. 81b

Despite the "middle-period" opus number, the Sextet (Op. 8Ib) dates from about 1795; it was published in 1810. Harold C. Schonberg, the senior music critic of the New York Times from 1960 to l980. called it "energetic and derivative," although he allowed that it contained some bearish lumberings of the giant to come." The sextet was written at about the same time Beethoven was working on a vanished Oboe Concerto and the first version of the Wind Octet (Op. 103 -- another misleading opus number). Indeed, almost all of Beethoven's chamber works for solo winds predate the 19th century: the part-writing throughout the Sextet is idiomatic and self-assured.


Listen to the Minuetto from Beethoven's Duo in E-Flat "And Two Obbligato Eyeglasses"

Finally, there is the Duo in E-flat for Viola and Cello "And Two Obbligato Eyeglasses," an odd little piece written sometime around 1796 but never published until 1912, after which  it   became  a   favorite  of  the   cellist Emanuel Feuermann (who made a fine recording with Willam Prinrose). In 1952, a second movement, in minuet style, was published; the "complete" version is the one recorded here. Beethoven wrote this piece for his friend Nikolaus Zmoskull von Domanovecz, a cellist, and apparently used to play it through with him (in addition to his expertise on the piano, Beethoven was a good enough violist to play the instrument in the Bonn orchestra tor a time). The reference to "obligato eyeglasses” seems to be a private joke referring to the myopia of the two original performers. This is Beethoven's only composition for this particular combination of instruments (there exists a duet in A for two violins dating from 1822) and it has been taken up by many violists and cellists with and without eyeglasses!

 

Note: this essay combines a story by David M. Greene with liner notes by Tim Page.


<h2>REDISCOVER THE JOY OF LISTENING</h2>

REDISCOVER THE JOY OF LISTENING

Get discounts on almost every purchase - and see about benefits from our partner store, ClassicSelect World.

Back to Exploring Music Home Page
BACK TO THIS MONTH'S MUSICAL HERITAGE REVIEW